The Manipulative Nature of Public Proposals

Friday, May. 27th 2011 10:36 PM

The scene is set. You’ve got a ring in your pocket and all your closest friends and family members gathered to witness you pop the question. Your proposal will be romantic and unforgettable … but unless you’re sure about your lover’s answer, it will also be manipulative.

I recently watched the reunion show of “Love & Hip Hop,” where Chrissy, rapper Jim Jones’ love interest, invited friends and family to an event where she planned to propose. Before they showed what happened that night, the show ran footage of her discussing her feelings about it with the other cast members. She explained:

I am tired of wasting time. What are we doing? If you are not going to step up and decide, then I am going to help you. I don’t want to force him into anything, but I want to know what’s going on. Are we going forward? Are we at a stand-still? It has to be movement. One way or another.

As I watched the proposal, I thought, “How manipulative!” Chrissy orchestrated this scene to coerce Jones into marriage. After all, he would risk looking like a fool (or making her look foolish) by telling her, “No, I will not marry you,” in front of all those people – and a television audience. He attempted to sidestep the question and save face for both of them by simply saying, “I am with you.” But she pushed the issue further, telling him that they were living in sin and if he didn’t “get it together” and marry her in less than three years, they would be living in separate households.

In a previous blog, “‘We’ May Not Be Representative of Me,” I wrote about how using the word “we” to describe what you think or feel is manipulative, because in speaking for your partner, you put pressure on him/her to agree – even if that is not the case. To propose marriage in front of other people without knowing for sure that your partner wants the same thing takes this type of manipulation to a whole new level.

Manipulation didn’t work for Chrissy in this situation. But if it had, if he had said “yes” to spare them both some embarrassment, how healthy do you really think that marriage would have been? I certainly wouldn’t want someone to marry me just to save face, and I wouldn’t be very happy in a marriage with someone who used other people to get her way with me.

On this matter, and possibly any matter, the classiest woman I have ever known (or heard about) is my mate. After the birth of our first son, she made it clear to me that she wanted to get married. Having been through one divorce, I told her that I wanted to be with her but not legally. We could continue to grow in our relationship through shared experiences, ventures, residences, children and whatever else husbands and wives do, but I did not want to get married again.

“OK, we don’t have to get married,” she said. “But know that I would like to get married in my lifetime.” That was the end of the conversation. The irony is that we eventually went through with the nuptials. Why I changed my mind is a story for another time, but it did not require any manipulation, coercion or public embarrassment.

If you want to make your engagement official in front of those you love, talk to your partner before your public proposal. Make sure he/she wants to marry you (or get married at all, for that matter). Respect his/her decision-making process and provide the space he/she needs to make it. If being legally wed is what you are after, resign yourself to the possibility that you may not get it with your current mate. But if you are after partnership, don’t write off the idea that a successful long-term relationship may not require wedding vows.

After all, understanding that our partners want what they want as much as we want what we want is the very foundation of being a Powerful Person in a Partnership.

Keep rising,

Frank Love
www.FrankLove.com

PS: To become a Frank Love sponsor you can make a one-time contribution or contribute monthly by clicking on the amount you’d like to donate each month: $1, $2, $5, $10, $20, $35, $50, $75, $100, $200 or $500.

 

…and please do not multi-task when driving.

Enter your email address here to receive Frank Love’s latest article via email: 

Print Friendly
Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Google Buzz
  • LinkedIn
  • PDF
  • Print
  • Reddit

Leave a Comment: Let Us Know Your Thoughts

How to Gracefully Exit a Relationship

6 Comments on “The Manipulative Nature of Public Proposals”

  1. Ana Polnerova Says:

    Being on the receiving end of the proposal, I can assume that it could be quite embarrassing for the male and maybe even hinder him in future proposals if he is not sure of the answer. Tough decision for him. Or one could say, a brave soul.

  2. Jeannine Vegh Says:

    I agree. These public proposals are becomming more and more commonplace and I always have this feeling of embarrassment for the couple. It is manipulative, but no more than these shows about “Bridezillas,” set the standards for women to think this is how they need to be on their wedding day. Both of them take away from actual communication in regards to the future, and put more of an emphasis on one day vs. the rest of their lives. I wonder what the statistics are for the marriages in both the public proposals and the bridezillas. I’d be willing to bet they are short.

  3. Nicole Says:

    Manipulative? Maybe so. But what about having the strength to be consistent with who you are and what you are about? Saying no was always an option. If Jim Jones was manipulated, he chose to be. He could have said “no, I’m not ready”. And he could have said it in a way that didn’t destroy her feelings. It wasn’t that he wasn’t aware of them, he didn’t want to acknowledge them. I believe that he was afraid to be honest because if he was clear and honest that he didn’t want to get married, then she would/could decide to leave him. They constantly manipulate each other. Seems to be the way that they work together.

  4. Massander Says:

    Your post on “‘We’ may not be representative of me” is one of the best ones I have read. It has stuck with me to this day and has helped me clear up plenty of misunderstandings before they got too far. Thanks.

    I hear where you’re going with the post about manipulation; however, I must say that I think that both parties are gonna get whatever they really make happen. If she simply wants to have a wedding, then she can have that. But if she wants a marriage and a powerful relationship, then that’s an entirely different thing. Time will tell what she really wanted and one way or another, she’ll have to deal with the repercussions of her choices, whether good or bad.

  5. Jody Worsfold Says:

    Well written Frank, manipulation of any form in a relationship isn’t healthy. A strong relationship is built on mutual love and respect; not deceit and manipulation.

  6. Diane Tomkin, R.D., C,D.N. Says:

    Well written article and very indicative of the things we hear about in many relationships today. A healthy relationship is built on honesty, openess, trust and respect. How can a couple even get that far in their relationship without ever discussing or knowing what their partner feels. I’m suprised that some relationships last as long as they do.

Leave a Reply